Vrunda and Associates Practising Company Secretaries Request a consultation

Transactions · Tribunal

Mergers, amalgamations and corporate restructuring

A scheme is a document, a timetable and a hearing. We take all three — drafting the scheme, moving the application, carrying it through sanction, and closing the filings and records that have to agree with the order afterwards.

First decision

Tribunal route or fast track

This is settled before anything is drafted, because it decides the cost, the calendar and who you end up in front of.

Sections 230–232

Scheme before the Tribunal

The general route, and the only route where creditors are compromised, a listed company is involved, or the companies do not fit the fast-track conditions. Two motions, meetings of members and creditors unless dispensed with, notice to every authority concerned, and sanction by order.

Companies Act, 2013 — ss. 230–232 · CAA Rules, 2016 · Forms CAA-1 to CAA-7
Section 233

Fast-track merger

Available between two or more small companies, between a holding company and its wholly-owned subsidiary, and for the other classes the Act and the rules now permit. It runs before the Regional Director instead of the Tribunal, with declarations of solvency and approval thresholds from members and creditors. Materially faster when the group qualifies.

Companies Act, 2013 — s. 233 · Rule 25, CAA Rules, 2016 · Forms CAA-9 to CAA-12

The conditions for the fast-track route have been widened more than once

Rule 25 of the CAA Rules has been amended several times since 2016 to bring further classes of companies into section 233. We check the position in force on the date of the application rather than working from the version we last used.

The timetable

What happens, in what order

The Tribunal route, step by step. Indicative durations only — the hearing calendar of the bench and the responses of the authorities drive the real timetable.

  1. 01

    Preparation

    Valuation, exchange ratio, scheme drafting, board approvals, and the auditor’s certificate on accounting treatment.

  2. 02

    Exchange no-objection

    Where a listed company is a party: observation letters through SEBI under LODR Reg. 37.

  3. 03

    First motion — Form CAA-2

    Application to the Tribunal with affidavits, the scheme and the disclosures.

  4. 04

    Directions order

    The Tribunal directs meetings of members and classes of creditors — or dispenses with them.

  5. 05

    Notices — CAA-3 and CAA-4

    To members and creditors with the explanatory statement, and to the Central Government, Registrar, Official Liquidator, income-tax authorities and every sectoral regulator.

  6. 06

    Meetings

    Held as directed; the chairperson’s report goes back to the Tribunal.

  7. 07

    Second motion — Form CAA-5

    Petition for sanction, representations of the authorities answered, hearing.

  8. 08

    Sanction

    The order sanctioning the scheme, in Form CAA-6 or CAA-7.

  9. 09

    Post-order

    Certified copy in Form INC-28, assets and liabilities transferred, transferor dissolved without winding up, and the PAN, GST, bank and licence records aligned.

Indicative sequence. The bench’s hearing calendar and the responses of the authorities drive the real timetable.

Paperwork

What a scheme actually needs behind it

The application is the visible part. These are the documents that have to exist and agree with one another before it is filed.

From the companies

  • Scheme of arrangement as approved by each board
  • Board resolutions of every company that is a party
  • Audited financial statements, and provisional accounts not older than the prescribed period
  • Memorandum and articles of each company
  • List of members and of secured and unsecured creditors, certified as on the cut-off date
  • Details of pending proceedings, investigations and winding-up petitions

From professionals and authorities

  • Registered valuer’s report on the share-exchange ratio
  • Auditor’s certificate on the accounting treatment under section 133
  • Certificate of no objection or observation letters from the stock exchanges, where listed
  • Representations of the Central Government, Registrar and Official Liquidator
  • Income-tax and sectoral regulator responses to the notice
  • Affidavits, vakalatnama or memorandum of appearance, and the Tribunal fee record

Beyond mergers

The rest of the restructuring work

Demerger and business transfer

Carving a division out by scheme, or by slump sale where a scheme is not required. The choice turns on liabilities, consideration and tax.

Reduction of share capital

Used to extinguish losses, return surplus capital, or clean up a cap table before an investment.

s. 66
Buy-back of securities

Approval route, solvency and ratio conditions, the SH-8 to SH-11 trail, and extinguishment.

s. 68
Conversion of entity form

Private to public and back, company to LLP, LLP to company, section 8 — each with its own consents.

Group simplification

Collapsing dormant and duplicate entities through fast-track mergers, strike-off or liquidation, in the order that costs least.

Cross-border mergers

Mergers involving a foreign company, with the RBI cross-border merger regulations.

s. 234 r/w Rule 25A

Questions

What promoters usually ask first

How long does a scheme take?

The fast-track route under section 233 is the shorter one because there is no Tribunal hearing. A Tribunal scheme under sections 230 to 232 depends on the bench’s calendar and on how quickly the Central Government, the Registrar, the Official Liquidator and the income-tax authorities respond to the notices. We give an estimate after reading the facts, and we do not promise a date, because the date is not ours to give.

Can the appointed date be backdated?

The scheme states the appointed date, and it may be a date earlier than the order. The Ministry of Corporate Affairs has issued a circular on how the appointed date and the acquisition date interact for accounting purposes. We set it with the auditor and the valuer, with the accounting treatment stated in the scheme itself.

Do all the creditors have to agree?

Under sections 230 to 232 the Tribunal may direct meetings of creditors or dispense with them, and the statute sets the majority required. Under section 233 the approval thresholds for members and creditors are prescribed in the section itself. Which creditors are affected at all depends on what the scheme does to their rights — a plain amalgamation between group companies and a compromise of debt are very different applications.

What happens to the transferor company’s registrations?

They do not transfer themselves. PAN, GST, bank accounts, licences, leases, employee records and the charge records all have to be migrated or re-registered after the order is filed. This is the stage most often left half-done, and it is part of the engagement rather than an afterthought.

Is a registered valuer always needed?

Where shares are issued as consideration, a valuation report supporting the share-exchange ratio is expected. We work with registered valuers on the report and make sure the ratio in the scheme, the valuation and the accounting treatment all say the same thing — a mismatch between those three is a common reason for queries at the hearing.

Considering a merger or a group reorganisation?

Send us the group structure and what you want to end up with. The first answer is which route the group qualifies for.